Skip to content

Estimation

Common design

  • Sample. All survey-based models are estimated on the estimation half of the travel survey; the land-use models of residential location and car ownership on ACS PUMS households.
  • Weights. The survey is stratified by home location, which every model except residential location takes as given, so these models are estimated without weights. Weights are used only where the sample is selected on the outcome: the PUMA level of residential location (whose sample is selected on origin and destination inside the zone-system area) and the work tour mode choice (whose sample over-represents rail commuters; weighted exogenous sample maximum likelihood).
  • Location probabilities. A survey location known by traffic zone or tract may cover several model zones; its probability is the sum of the probabilities of those zones, weighted by housing units, enrolment or jobs.
  • Choice sets. School and activity-location models use the full choice set of 1,588 zones; workplace choice the chosen zone and 99 sampled zones; the PUMA level of residential location all 97 PUMAs, and the dwelling level 30 sampled alternatives.
  • Specification search. Each model is built in blocks of variables from a basic model. A block is kept when its likelihood-ratio test is significant at 5 %, it lowers the BIC and its signs are as expected; non-nested forms are compared by BIC.
  • Standard errors are robust (sandwich).
  • Hold-out. The hold-out half was consulted more than once in the specification search of several models, so its fit is not a fully independent test.
  • Software: Python Biogeme for every model of the estimation package.

All estimated models

The full results of every model, coefficient by coefficient, are in Estimated models.

\(N\): observations; \(K\): parameters; LL: log-likelihood at the estimates; \(\bar\rho^2\): adjusted rho-square. Hold-out: log-likelihood per mover (residential location), \(\rho^2\) (car ownership), log-likelihood per record (workplace, schools, locations) or total log-likelihood (tour formation and mode) on held-out data.

Model (alternatives) \(N\) \(K\) LL \(\bar\rho^2\) Hold-out
Land use and workplace
Residential location: PUMA (97)1 15,163 14 −34,670.3 0.500 −2.297
Residential location: dwelling (30 sampled) 15,163 18 −47,478.6 0.079 −3.115
Car ownership (4) 91,348 56 −78,613.6 0.379 0.375
Workplace (100 sampled) 9,707 24 −21,376.5 0.521 −4.8112
Schools (full choice set)
K–8 (1,144 zones) 1,509 13 −2,885.6 0.721 −1.953
High school (719 zones) 668 6 −1,217.0 0.722 −1.810
College (141 zones) 673 9 −1,810.4 0.454 −2.789
MAST: locations (1,588 zones)
Main activity, four purposes (pooled) 14,341 62 −49,427.4 0.532 −3.370
Stop: shopping 3,979 23 −9,982.6 0.659 −2.527
Stop: recreation 5,064 20 −15,874.9 0.574 −3.205
Stop: accompanying 3,515 22 −12,488.1 0.517 −3.396
Stop: other errands 8,055 20 −24,653.3 0.584 −3.028
Outing from the workplace: first stop 1,180 10 −3,112.3 0.663 −2.707
Work business: usual-workplace workers 1,539 18 −8,432.1 0.310 −5.554
Work business: other persons 1,259 16 −6,819.3 0.292 −5.625
Work trips of home workers 366 5 −1,640.9 0.430 −4.389
School without record; daycare (pooled) 846 9 −3,798.5 0.440 −4.396
MAST: tour formation and mode
Outing from the workplace (2) 8,613 8 −3,061.5 0.486 −3,093.2
Mode of the outing (2) 1,177 7 −360.6 0.549 −299.8
Return home (2) 28,349 33 −13,697.0 0.301 −13,771.8
Tour mode: work (6)3 9,126 51 −4,313.1 0.626 −4,284.0
Tour mode: school (6) 2,651 34 −972.5 0.651 −1,096.5
Tour mode: shopping (6) 3,206 44 −1,150.2 0.713 −1,107.0
Tour mode: other (6, nested) 10,405 57 −4,916.7 0.623 −5,049.8
Joint shopping (5) 452 15 −112.8 0.780 −94.0
Joint recreation and other (6) 1,296 25 −450.3 0.710 −459.1
Transit-tour legs (5)4 6,773 35 −3,421.5 0.621 −3,291.0

1. Weighted by the expected in-area share of origin and destination; inclusive value of the dwelling level with coefficient 1. 2. Full choice set of 1,587 zones with jobs. 3. Choice-based sample weights (weighted pseudo-log-likelihood). 4. Car driver available only with a household car that is free over the tour window.

The synthetic population (CVAE) is not a likelihood model; its fit is reported in validation. The activity distributions of MAST are 3,946 weighted relative frequencies of the estimation half.

Linking logsums

Three logsums connect the models:

  • Mode-choice logsum of a person between two zones for a purpose, from the tour mode model; it enters the stop models as the logsum detour.
  • Non-work accessibility of a zone, the destination-choice logsum over all 1,588 zones for shopping, recreation, accompanying and other trips, weighted by trip shares (0.329, 0.279, 0.148, 0.243). It enters car ownership as the accessibility gained from a car.
  • Inclusive value of the dwelling level in the PUMA level of residential location.

Re-estimating the models yourself

Every model can be re-estimated from its data with Python Biogeme; see the estimation package.