Skip to content

Land use and workplaces

Residential location (two levels: PUMA, then dwelling), car ownership and workplace choice. The residential and car-ownership models are estimated on ACS PUMS households, the workplace model on the estimation half of the 2017/18 Regional Travel Survey.

Reading the tables

Coefficient: maximum-likelihood estimate, with significance stars *** p < 0.01, ** p < 0.05, * p < 0.10; robust (sandwich) standard error; two-sided p-value. N: observations; K: estimated parameters; LL(β̂): log-likelihood at the estimates; ρ̄²: adjusted rho-square. Hold-out: fit on the held-out half of the data, which was also used in the specification search. "Reference": the omitted category; "—": removed from the model.

Residential location: PUMA

Upper level: the PUMA a moving household chooses among the 97 PUMAs of the zone-system area, with the inclusive value of the dwelling level (coefficient held at 1), the market size, distance from the previous home, the commute, PUMA attributes and the share of the PUMA's households whose householder is of the mover's race category. ACS PUMS movers 2014–2018.

N = 15,163K = 14LL(β̂) = −34,670.3 (weighted)ρ̄² = 0.500Hold-out: LL per mover −2.297
Variable Coefficient Robust s.e. p
Inclusive value of the dwelling level
Inclusive value IVp 1 fixed
Size of the market
Ln market size Mp 0.8397*** 0.0323 <0.001
Car time from the previous home (per min)
Under 20 min 0 fixed
20–60 min −0.0339*** 0.0015 <0.001
Over 60 min −0.0087*** 0.0006 <0.001
Staying near the origin
Inside the previous migration area 2.5267*** 0.0851 <0.001
Bordering the previous migration area 1.3297*** 0.0540 <0.001
Same state as the origin 1.0820*** 0.0347 <0.001
Commute
Commute: Σworkers ln(1+t) −1.7408*** 0.0283 <0.001
PUMA attributes
Crime index × children −1.1607*** 0.1142 <0.001
Ln dwelling density −0.5466*** 0.0196 <0.001
 × single-person household 0.1698*** 0.0229 <0.001
 × oldest member under 35 0.2446*** 0.0217 <0.001
 × ln income −0.1153*** 0.0105 <0.001
Core-city share (DC, Baltimore City) 0.5055*** 0.0401 <0.001
Own-race share of the PUMA's households 2.0759*** 0.0518 <0.001

Observations: 15,163 ACS PUMS movers 2014–2018 (estimation sample), weighted by the expected in-area share of origin and destination (mean 1); alternatives: the 97 PUMAs of the zone-system area, all available (no sampling); parameters: 14. Inclusive value: ln of the mean of exp V of the dwelling level over 200 dwellings drawn at random from the PUMA's movers' dwellings; ln Mp enters as its own term. Market size: Mp = rp × dwellings of the PUMA, with the fixed turnover rate rp = PUMS dwellings of recent movers (moved in within 12 months) × the PUMA's share of housing units in the zone system / 2016 dwellings of the PUMA; in the simulation Mp changes only with construction and demolition. LL(0) = −69,366.3; LL(β̂) = −34,670.3 (weighted); ρ² = 0.500; AIC = 69,368.6; BIC = 69,475.4. Hold-out movers (3,820; this half was also used in the specification search; unweighted): LL = −8,773.2, −2.297 per mover. Car time applies to the part of the move outside the previous migration area; no effect below 20 min. Previous migration area: share of the dwellings of the household's migration PUMA (ACS) that lie in the PUMA. Commute t: peak car time (min) from the PUMA to the jobs of the worker's place-of-work PUMA, transit door-to-door time for households without a car. Own-race share: share of the PUMA's households whose householder is of the mover's race category (white, Black, Hispanic, other); 2016 in estimation, recomputed every year in the simulation. Density interactions: the main density coefficient is that of a household of $50k with two or more persons and an oldest member of 35 or older; ln income = ln(income / $50k). Core-city share: share of the PUMA's dwellings in DC or Baltimore City (zones weighted as for the other attributes). Dependent variable: destination PUMA of ACS PUMS movers 2014–2018 (estimation sample).

Residential location: destination PUMAs of the hold-out movers, observed and model, and model minus observed.

Residential location: destination PUMAs of the hold-out movers, observed and model, and model minus observed.

Residential location: dwelling

Lower level: the dwelling within the chosen PUMA, among the chosen dwelling and 29 drawn at random from the PUMA's dwellings of recent movers. Each term also enters times ln income. ACS PUMS movers 2014–2018.

N = 15,163K = 18LL(β̂) = −47,478.6ρ̄² = 0.079Hold-out: LL per mover −3.115
Variable Coefficient Robust s.e. p
Affordability
Cost above 30 % of income (share) −4.5411*** 0.1518 <0.001
 × ln income −1.9322*** 0.0686 <0.001
Quality
Ln monthly housing cost 0.4398*** 0.0256 <0.001
 × ln income 0.2652*** 0.0262 <0.001
Size and age of the dwelling
Bedroom shortfall (per bedroom) −0.6566*** 0.0166 <0.001
 × ln income −0.1424*** 0.0169 <0.001
Bedroom excess (per bedroom) −0.5353*** 0.0176 <0.001
 × ln income 0.1621*** 0.0179 <0.001
Built in the last five years −0.0414 0.0363 0.253
 × ln income 0.1306*** 0.0351 <0.001
Structure type (reference: single-family detached)
Single-family attached 0.0314 0.0292 0.282
 × ln income −0.1641*** 0.0309 <0.001
Multifamily 2–4 units −0.1255*** 0.0404 0.002
 × ln income −0.3343*** 0.0414 <0.001
Multifamily 5+ units −0.0781** 0.0316 0.014
 × ln income −0.3099*** 0.0344 <0.001
Mobile home or other −0.2092*** 0.0707 0.003
 × ln income −0.4727*** 0.0654 <0.001

Observations: 15,163 ACS PUMS movers 2014–2018 (estimation sample, unweighted); alternatives: 30 (chosen + 29 drawn uniformly from the PUMA's dwellings occupied by recent movers); parameters: 18. Choice set: the mover's dwelling and 29 dwellings drawn uniformly at random from the PUMA's market of movers' dwellings. A uniform draw gives consistent estimates and costs only precision (McFadden, 1978); with a second draw, or with 60 or 100 alternatives, no coefficient moves by more than 0.67 robust s.e. In SILO the household sees 30 vacant dwellings drawn at random in the chosen PUMA (all if fewer). LL(0) = −51,572.4; LL(β̂) = −47,478.6; ρ² = 0.079; AIC = 94,993.2; BIC = 95,130.5. Hold-out movers (3,820; this half was also used in the specification search): LL = −11,900.3, −3.115 per mover. Cost above 30 % of income: \max(0, 12 × cost / income - 0.30), income at least $5k, share at most 3; 30 % is the standard housing-cost-burden threshold (fixed). Cost: gross rent (renters) or selected monthly owner costs (owners), 2016 $; ln cost of at least $100. Income: ln(household income / $50k), 2016 $. Bedroom need: household size (at most 5).

Car ownership

Multinomial logit over 0, 1, 2 and 3 or more cars; every variable has its own coefficient for each alternative (no car = reference). The Baltimore City term is estimated with the other coefficients; no constant is calibrated. Maryland ACS PUMS households 2014–2018.

N = 91,348K = 56LL(β̂) = −78,613.6ρ̄² = 0.379Hold-out: ρ² 0.375
Variable Coefficient Robust s.e. p
One car versus none
Constant 1.2652*** 0.1440 <0.001
Workers 0.1062*** 0.0300 <0.001
Persons aged 16+: 2 −0.6235*** 0.0566 <0.001
Persons aged 16+: 3 −1.3456*** 0.0764 <0.001
Persons aged 16+: 4 or more −1.6925*** 0.1020 <0.001
Children under 16 −0.2038*** 0.0230 <0.001
Single-person household −0.2501*** 0.0508 <0.001
Age of the oldest member ((age − 45) / 10) −0.0656*** 0.0104 <0.001
Age of the oldest member, squared −0.0347*** 0.0036 <0.001
Ln income, slope under $25k 0.5127*** 0.0367 <0.001
Ln income, slope $25–50k 1.4038*** 0.0872 <0.001
Ln income, slope $50–100k 0.3798*** 0.0999 <0.001
Ln income, slope above $100k −0.2813*** 0.1000 0.005
Single-family attached and other dwelling reference
Single-family detached dwelling 0.2074*** 0.0444 <0.001
Multifamily dwelling −0.3958*** 0.0424 <0.001
Bedrooms 0.3471*** 0.0206 <0.001
Ln dwelling density of the PUMA (per km²) —
Non-work accessibility gain from a car (logsum) 0.4632*** 0.1210 <0.001
Ln income × ln dwelling density (centred) 0.0616*** 0.0105 <0.001
Baltimore City −0.9227*** 0.0430 <0.001
Two cars versus none
Constant −1.2532*** 0.1889 <0.001
Workers 0.3319*** 0.0311 <0.001
Persons aged 16+: 2 2.0214*** 0.0404 <0.001
Persons aged 16+: 3 1.0266*** 0.0662 <0.001
Persons aged 16+: 4 or more 0.3075*** 0.0970 0.002
Children under 16 −0.1821*** 0.0227 <0.001
Single-person household —
Age of the oldest member ((age − 45) / 10) −0.1364*** 0.0102 <0.001
Age of the oldest member, squared −0.0459*** 0.0040 <0.001
Ln income, slope under $25k 0.3837*** 0.0537 <0.001
Ln income, slope $25–50k 1.9106*** 0.1052 <0.001
Ln income, slope $50–100k 1.2820*** 0.1040 <0.001
Ln income, slope above $100k 0.1458 0.1004 0.146
Single-family attached and other dwelling reference
Single-family detached dwelling 0.7446*** 0.0475 <0.001
Multifamily dwelling −0.9090*** 0.0485 <0.001
Bedrooms 0.5272*** 0.0230 <0.001
Ln dwelling density of the PUMA (per km²) −0.1391*** 0.0105 <0.001
Non-work accessibility gain from a car (logsum) 0.6501*** 0.1480 <0.001
Ln income × ln dwelling density (centred) 0.0285** 0.0128 0.026
Baltimore City −1.1812*** 0.0523 <0.001
Three or more cars versus none
Constant −3.6183*** 0.2405 <0.001
Workers 0.6294*** 0.0327 <0.001
Persons aged 16+: 2 2.1165*** 0.0545 <0.001
Persons aged 16+: 3 2.6169*** 0.0755 <0.001
Persons aged 16+: 4 or more 2.3784*** 0.1026 <0.001
Children under 16 −0.3410*** 0.0243 <0.001
Single-person household —
Age of the oldest member ((age − 45) / 10) —
Age of the oldest member, squared −0.0958*** 0.0040 <0.001
Ln income, slope under $25k 0.1625* 0.0834 0.051
Ln income, slope $25–50k 2.0388*** 0.1393 <0.001
Ln income, slope $50–100k 1.4880*** 0.1141 <0.001
Ln income, slope above $100k 0.2811*** 0.1027 0.006
Single-family attached and other dwelling reference
Single-family detached dwelling 1.4866*** 0.0530 <0.001
Multifamily dwelling −1.3346*** 0.0676 <0.001
Bedrooms 0.6396*** 0.0252 <0.001
Ln dwelling density of the PUMA (per km²) −0.3054*** 0.0139 <0.001
Non-work accessibility gain from a car (logsum) 1.1430*** 0.1783 <0.001
Ln income × ln dwelling density (centred) −0.0299** 0.0150 0.047
Baltimore City −1.0775*** 0.0671 <0.001

Observations: 91,348 Maryland households (ACS PUMS 2014–2018, estimation sample: 80%); alternatives: 4 (0, 1, 2, 3 or more cars); parameters: 56. LL(0) = −126,635.2; LL(constants) = −116,008.5; LL(β̂) = −78,613.6; ρ² = 0.379; ρ² against constants = 0.322; AIC = 157,339.2; BIC = 157,866.9. Hold-out sample (20%, 22,730 households): LL(0) = −31,510.5; LL(β̂) = −19,704.5; ρ² = 0.375. The hold-out sample was also used in the specification search. Estimation: unweighted multinomial logit (maximum likelihood, Newton); robust (sandwich) standard errors. Income in 2016 $, ln(income / $50k), at least $5k, piecewise linear with bends at $25k, $50k and $100k. Density centred at its mean (5.49). Persons aged 16+: reference 0 or 1. Baltimore City: estimated with the other coefficients; it captures what makes the City different (transit, parking, history) and is not a behavioural effect. The accessibility gain is that of the household's income group (under $40k, $40–75k, $75–125k, $125k or more). —: fixed at 0 (p > 0.3 when estimated).

Workplace choice

Choice of the workplace zone, with the chosen zone and 99 zones drawn at random from the 1,587 zones with jobs; 24 parameters. Survey estimation half.

N = 9,707K = 24LL(β̂) = −21,376.5ρ̄² = 0.521Hold-out: LL per worker −4.811 (all zones)
Variable Coefficient Robust s.e. p
Size
Size coefficient μ (ln of total jobs) 0.8369*** 0.0122 <0.001
Car time
Time (min) −0.0701*** 0.0031 <0.001
Ln(1+time) −0.4756*** 0.1015 <0.001
Car time × person
Time × woman −0.0158*** 0.0017 <0.001
Time × age 30–54 reference
Time × age <30 −0.0164*** 0.0029 <0.001
Time × age 55+ −0.0057*** 0.0020 0.004
Time × income $40–75k reference
Time × income <$40k −0.0179*** 0.0055 0.001
Time × income $75–125k 0.0068*** 0.0024 0.005
Time × income $125k+ 0.0107*** 0.0026 <0.001
Time × driving licence 0.0236*** 0.0072 0.001
Time × household size −0.0018** 0.0007 0.012
Time × rural home zone 0.0058*** 0.0018 0.002
Time × household without a car −0.0203*** 0.0074 0.006
Borders and the District
Same zone 0.6814*** 0.0865 <0.001
Other county −0.2653*** 0.0368 <0.001
Other state −0.6772*** 0.0496 <0.001
DC workplace, home outside DC 0.8340*** 0.0531 <0.001
Job mix × person
Office share × income $40k or more reference
Office share × income <$40k −0.7702*** 0.2432 0.002
Retail share × age <30 1.5432*** 0.1977 <0.001
Industrial share × woman −1.4910*** 0.1285 <0.001
Wage proxy
High-wage share 1.5238*** 0.1751 <0.001
High-wage share × income $40–75k reference
High-wage share × income <$40k −0.8870** 0.3839 0.021
High-wage share × income $75–125k 1.1052*** 0.2005 <0.001
High-wage share × income $125k+ 1.7629*** 0.2076 <0.001

Observations: 9,707 workers; alternatives: chosen zone + 99 zones sampled uniformly from the 1,587 zones with jobs (no correction needed); parameters: 24. LL(0) = −44,702.4; LL(β̂) = −21,376.5; ρ² = 0.522; AIC = 42,801.1; BIC = 42,973.4. Hold-out half (9,749 workers, all 1,587 zones; also used in the specification search): LL = −46,905.5 (−4.811 per worker). Estimation: maximum likelihood with analytic gradient; robust (sandwich) standard errors. Dependent variable: zone of the usual workplace of workers with a fixed workplace outside their home (estimation half of the Regional Travel Survey 2017/18). Size term μln Sj, Sj = total jobs of the zone (the four job types weighted equally). Income groups: reference $40–75k. Car time: peak car time home–workplace (min). Shares: job shares of the workplace zone; high-wage share: share of high-earning jobs. Person variables in the time interactions are centred at their estimation-half means, so the time coefficient is the effect for the mean worker.

Workplace choice: estimates with 95 % robust intervals.

Workplace choice: estimates with 95 % robust intervals.

Workplace choice: workplaces of the hold-out workers by PUMA, observed and model, and model minus observed.

Workplace choice: workplaces of the hold-out workers by PUMA, observed and model, and model minus observed.